Somewhere in the first week of January 2027, in a hall with the blinds down, a slide will be emblazoned with the familiar call: 'every teacher is a teacher of literacy'.

Some staff will nod agreeably, whereas others will fold their arms. Most will wonder how long this is going to take before they can go and sort through their classrooms ready for the pupils being back.

The line that has morphed over time originally belongs to George Sampson, a teacher and school inspector, who wrote in 1921 that "every teacher is a teacher of English because every teacher is a teacher in English". He thought the sentence deserved carving in gold above the door of every school.

Half a century later, the Bullock Report said it again, in different words, urging every school to hold a policy for language across the curriculum. Successive national curricula, inspection frameworks, and school improvement plans have restated it ever since, with mixed success at best.

After a century of imploring it, daily reading among children and teenagers flatlining and lots of them struggling with basic literacy. 2026 is the Year of Reading. We may make a claim to make 2027 the same...and 2028...

When something has been stated clearly, repeatedly and with authority for a hundred years, and still hasn't happened, we should stop treating it as a communication problem.

Problems with passionate slogans

There are some predictable problems with Sampson's impassioned call to teach English - or the broader (and potentially fuzzier) literacy across the curriculum.

First, it is a call to action rather than a practice. It tells teachers to care about something, but I've never met a teacher who didn't think reading and writing skills were not valuable. I have met teachers who were unclear what practices would actually make a difference in their classroom on a cold, wet Tuesday morning.

Second, it asks for the wrong thing.

Heard plainly, every teacher is a teacher of English asks for a second subject to be bolted on to the first. So, we take on the parts of English that are easiest to recognise: circling spellings, insisting on full sentences, or policing rogue apostrophes. Meanwhile the literacy that is actually doing most of the work in the subject goes untaught, because it doesn't look enough like English.

It does not look like English because it is history, or science, or maths. A Year 4 class reading an eyewitness account of the Great Fire will read it as a story unless somebody teaches them that it is evidence, and that the person writing it had a particular perspective. A physics class reads a diagram and a paragraph at the same time, in two directions, and uses 'work' and 'power' in ways that would baffle anyone outside the room.

None of that is English or literacy bolted onto the curriculum. It is the subject itself and it is the part that experienced teachers do so automatically we forget we ever learned it. This is why the ever-sage Geoff Barton called for us to do away with the word literacy and call it what great teachers do.

Lastly, the slogan attaches itself to no observable practices. Nothing changes, and nobody can tell whether it has, so we all just get on teaching like we always have. The literacy policy sits on the shared drive gathering electronic cobwebs.

The sentence we needed was never teach English as well as your subject. It was explicitly teach the language of your subject.

This is where the phrase disciplinary literacy has done positive work to evolve the debate and to move from slogans to subject specific practices. It is a trickier business though, because disciplinary literacy is not so easy to enact in a whole-school INSET. The experts who know how reading works in a topic are the people teaching it.

Disciplinary literacy is not some easy solution to the one hundred year challenge to improve reading, writing and communication.

There are complications. For example, in primary schools, literacy is general and subject specific at once - roots and branches of the same tree. A child who cannot yet decode fluently will not read that eyewitness account like a historian however well we teach evidence and bias. In primary classrooms the branches may be slender, but they are there, and they grow out of roots that still need feeding daily.

Replacing slogans with useful questions

The test of improving literacy - whatever we name it - will be whether a phase or department team can do something about what happens in the classroom with specific practices. Here are some useful questions prompts to that end:

Reading

  • What does reading actually look like in this topic or subject, and how would we know they were doing it successfully?
  • Of the reading set this week, how much was read, and how much was skimmed, guessed at or likely misunderstood?

Writing

  • What specific kinds of writing we genuinely require, and where are they taught rather than merely set?
  • Has anyone ever shown these children what a good one looks like and clarified the specific subject differences?

Oracy/talk

  • What counts as thinking well out loud in this subject, and would a child know it if they heard it?
  • Which children have not said anything in our lessons this week?

Vocabulary

  • Which twenty words carry the most weight the coming term, and who is teaching them explicitly?
  • Which everyday words quietly change meaning here (table, volume, force, interception, and cardinal) and do we clarify these vocabulary shifts?

Answer those, provide specific and manageable practices, and something might change on the next Tuesday morning. However small, a change may happen that does more than a slogan.

Or we can replay the slogan imploring in new year training sessions that every teacher is a teacher of literacy, or English, and file away the PPT slide ready to be dusted off for next year.

  • Read the Education Endowment Foundation guidance on secondary literacy that explores disciplinary literacy and much more HERE.
  • Geoff Barton has been one of the biggest influences in literacy, and shaping my ideas, and his book, 'Don't call it literacy', is seminal - see HERE.
  • In my latest book, 'Literacy essentials for every teacher', I've attempted to collate what busy teachers need to know and do on wet Tuesday mornings - see HERE. Get it at Routledge with 20% off too - just click the image for the link.
Newsletter

Subscribe to the newsletter

Alex Quigley.co.uk is a blog by the author, Alex Quigley - @AlexJQuigley - sharing ideas and evidence about education, teaching and learning.

success-filled

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.